Skip to main content

A Mexican-American Tug of War




The concept of a duel identity defining those Americans with ties to another non-white nation, has grown to an extreme level of prominence as the United States has come to be the mixing pot of ethnic and cultural identity. Labels such as African-American and Asian-American, and their extremely common usage, imply an inherent interconnection and overlap between the unique identities of two distinctly different lifestyles. Yet, despite the fact that these identification labels specifically implement the term “American,” history has shown that this is not usually sufficient to prevent racial prejudice that emphasizes the other identity referenced within the name. As George Sanchez outlines within Becoming Mexican-American, the term Mexican-American does not necessarily imply a cheerful blend of traditional Mexican cultural ties with American adjustments. Rather, the distinct identity that is Mexican-American is an internal tug of war between the two cultures that is combined with a requirement of adaptability when facing discrimination and prejudice. It is within Sanchez’s historical summary of the Mexican-American identity that he clarifies an important notion: the coming of the term “Mexican American” was not a natural process. Mexican migrants to the United States did not blend their cultures out of comfortable cultural assimilation. The stratification of Mexican-American populations by socioeconomic status in combination with the racial prejudice facing them, forced upon Mexican migrants the need to implement a sense of cultural moldability within their identity. In this way, the obligation of responding and adapting to discrimination of Mexican identity became ingrained within the Mexican American label. This not only creates an internal tug of war of embracing either the Mexican or American aspects of one’s identity, but it also creates a sense of instability in the fluid change of Mexican-American identification. The result is a continued struggle for Mexican migrants in the United States against ethnic discrimination, of which is manifested in the contemporary issue of immigration.